Ideas and Information Gaps
Thomas Hardy
Tamagawa University |
Quick Guide
Key Words: Gender issues
Learner English Level: Intermediate and above
Learner Maturity Level: Junior High and above
Preparation Time: Varies
Activity Time: One semester
Information gap exercises, where the information necessary to complete
a task is divided among two or more students, are a recognized way to get
students talking in the EFL classroom. In my classes on gender and social
inequality, I use them extensively to get students talking about received
notions of social relations in Japanese society, exploring the ways sex
and gender shape social inequalities in Japan today, and hopefully, have
them leave the course with a little greater self-awareness of their place
in society and alternatives to it.
The class starts with a discussion leading to a definition of inequality
based on an individual's access to wealth, power, and prestige. We then
discuss how society divides these resources depending on an individual's
membership in groups based on age, social class, ethnicity or race, and,
most importantly for this class sex and gender. This intellectual construction
is not particularly complex. But, simple as it is, it is new to my students
and provides a framework of ideas as they work their way into further discussions
on the nature and practice of social inequality.
Following a couple of short readings on gender inequalities in American
life, the students go to the movies. At this point I face a dilemma: I want
the students to have some depth of analysis and discussion, and at the same
time I want them exposed to a range of gender inequalities visible in American
popular culture. To get around this, I have students divide into small teams,
with three to five students per team. I assign each team a movie and its
members are responsible for the deeper analysis of that film. Each team
watches its movie outside of class (in the audio-visual library or at home
using a rented video) and, using a viewing work sheet I distribute, analyzes
the ways gender shapes the film's characters' access to wealth, power, and
prestige (see Figure A). I collect the viewing work sheets (this keeps students
from reading their analyses instead of giving interviews) and then have
students share their work with other students using a version of information
gap interviews: they use an interview work sheet I give them to get the
analyses of two experts on the gender inequalities apparent in two other
films (see Figure B). To a degree, this exercise gets around the dilemma
described earlier: It gives the students some depth in analyzing a selected
movie and some breadth as they share their analysis with other students
and hear other students' analyses of other films.
In the second part of the term, students take their skills at analyzing
gender inequalities in American society (and films) and use them on Japanese
films. Students watch films about women in Japan, using worksheets to analyze
the films in terms of gender inequalities of wealth, power, and prestige.
This is one way I have found to deal with the realities of teaching idea-based
EFL classes at university in Japan; twelve 90-minute class meetings spread
over four months, with little or no homework possible, and spotty attendance
place strong limits on the art of the possible. To counter this, I use films.
Students, in general like films and are predisposed to regard watching them
as fun. Giving students responsibility for a specific film or two allows
a certain amount of depth of analysis. The use of a structured set of ideas
(about gender-based limits on access to wealth, power, and prestige, in
this case) provides a frame in which students can approach the task with
confidence. The information gap format gets students talking, and it provides
a breadth of coverage of varied forrns of and responses to inequality that
would be difficult otherwise.
Figure A
American film viewing notes
Film:
Title
Director
Date made
Summary
Gender and inequality in the film:
Wealth:
Example
Example
Example
Example
(p.1) |
Power
Example
Example
Example
Prestige
Example
Example
Conclusions & comments
Name:
(p.2) |
Figure B
American film interview notes
Interview 2 students about gender and social inequality in American films.
Talk with your partner(s) about what you have leamed in the interviews.
Take notes on your discussion.
Interview 1
Student interviewed:
Film:
Summary:
Gender and inequality in the film
Wealth
Power
Prestige
Interview 2
Student interviewed:
Film:
Summary:
Gender and social rewards in the film
Wealth
Power
Prestige
(p.1) |
Discussion
.
Comments & conclusions
.
.
Name:
(p.2) |
Article copyright
© 1998 by the author.
Document URL: http://www.jalt-publications.org/old_tlt/files/98/may/sh_hardy.html
Last modified: May 21, 1998
Site maintained by TLT
Online Editor
|